I think it is time for me to remind everyone, again…
Important to note that in the original it was the “Communists” they came for not “Socialists”. Link (German)
There are in fact quite a number of revisions of the quote. I have discovered that with numerous quotes. They evolve.
Is it still a quote tho if it’s not a quote? 🤔
Since the admission admission of multiple quotes is from Niemöller any of the quotes from him should qualify.
Here’s some add’l info: Pastor Martin Niemöller’s poignant statement, commonly known as “First they came for…,” has undergone various adaptations since its inception in the mid-1940s. Originally delivered during his post-World War II lectures, Niemöller’s words were a candid admission of his own inaction and a call to recognize the perils of societal apathy.
The United States Holocaust Memorial Museum provides a widely recognized version of the quote:
First they came for the socialists, and I did not speak out—because I was not a socialist. Then they came for the trade unionists, and I did not speak out—because I was not a trade unionist. Then they came for the Jews, and I did not speak out—because I was not a Jew. Then they came for me—and there was no one left to speak for me.This version emphasizes the sequential persecution of different groups and the consequences of remaining silent. It’s important to note that Niemöller’s original speeches were impromptu, leading to multiple renditions of the statement over time. These variations reflect the evolving contexts in which the quote has been referenced and adapted.
For a comprehensive understanding of the quote’s origins and its different versions, you can refer to the United States Holocaust Memorial Museum’s article: encyclopedia.ushmm.org
Additionally, the Holocaust Memorial Day Trust offers another version of the quote, highlighting slight differences in wording and the groups mentioned: hmd.org.uk
These resources provide credible insights into the evolution and enduring significance of Niemöller’s statement.
The Quote of Theseus
Trans people can no longer get passports.
President Musk is a personally motivated transphobe.
Trans people are the first line in this iteration of the poem. We have already been abandoned by the Democratic party.
Make space for trans people in your lives.
Be prepared to help them shelter in place if necessary.
Instead of the Underground Railroad, this generation may have the Trans National Pipeline.
Sigh…
Fuck, I know its probably obvious and I’m wasting your time, what’s that movies name again?
I don’t know why Niemöller omitted them, but in fact trans people were the first line in that iteration, too.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Institut_für_Sexualwissenschaft#Nazi_era
he also omittet the victims of t4. the poem is supposed to communicate an idea, its not a full list of all victims of the nazis. Besides, i dont know wether niemöller even knew of transgender people.
Besides, i dont know wether niemöller even knew of transgender people.
That’s one reason why I didn’t speculate on the reason for the omission.
deleted by creator
They were first the last time too. That history had just been pretty much erased.
The Democratic party has no institutional power at the moment. Stop assessing blame to them and focus in who is allied and able to help.
Blaming the Democratic Party is completely useless, as useless as you believe them to be. In part they are captured, and in part they are literally in the jaws of a fascist government.
And you’re still blaming them for this moment. They might end up at GITMO.
Even if they have no institutional power, there are other groups the Democratic party is still talking about, still trying to take action on.
They aren’t even pretending to care about trans people any more.
That’s fair. I’d just rather see the left try to unify then assign blame and fall further to infighting.
We will need all the allies we can muster to pull through this.
I think the left is relatively united by the left’s standards.
The issue is that the Democratic party establishment is not part of the left.
Then we take it and remake it.
There is no time to create a new party and all recent efforts have failed.
I think that needs to take the form of other groups who are willing to vote in coalition with the democrats, but not part of them.
The democrats are far better than the Republicans at exactly one thing: crushing their base and excluding it from power.
I think the fastest option is to take over the party. If the right wing nut jobs could do it it the republicans, certainly we can as well.
Dems have no institutional power when they are the majority. They are ineffective in everything they do. And theyve enabled the current fascists in power.
Trans, like all other marginalized communities, were only ever pawns for power to the DNC. Used to obtain their goals then tossed aside when they were no longer needed.
Even this poem minimizes the fact that the Nazis came after LGBTQ+ folks first.
Because he was FOR that.
Also a VIRULENT anti-semite. He was a giant piece of shit who had a nice shocked Pikachu moment when Hitler went back on his deal to let protestant churches do whatever they wanted without nazi interference.
Yeah the Weimar Republic was many things and it was a pretty progressive place prior to 1933. Then it quickly changed.
Can we add the classic Don’t Be a Sucker? Similar message about paying attention to what’s happening to other people and not waiting until it’s your turn.
This one was shockingly accurate when I first saw it last year. Tragically, we turned out to be a nation of dumbass suckers.
“We human beings are not born with prejudices. Always they are made for us. Made by someone who wants something. Remember that when you hear this kind of talk - somebody is going to get something out of it, and it isn’t going to be you.”
The lesson of history is to first come for the Nazis.
