[a character holds and points at a book while speaking]
Of course I agree racism is bad
Anyway here’s my fantasy novel

[on the book’s cover, a lord watches over chained up slaves, and the book’s title reads]
What If Racism And Slavery Were Good Actually, The Book

https://thebad.website/comic/apolitical_fantasy

  • Ayutsu@lemmy.zip
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    9
    ·
    2 days ago

    “Don’t you see? They’ll never get anywhere on their own!” A real thing an old man told me 🫠

  • rumschlumpel@feddit.org
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    3
    ·
    2 days ago

    Fantasy and “people of this race are almost always evil, the exceptions are just exceptions”, name a more iconic duo…

    Fantasy that implies that slavery is good seems rare, though. You mentioned D&D and Drizzt (I assume the books) as examples, but I’ve only seen D&D/Drizzt content where slavery is either something you fight against as a quest, or a feature of a crap sack society that isn’t supposed to be viewed as good - would you mind listing some specific examples?

    • Bad@jlai.luOPM
      link
      fedilink
      English
      arrow-up
      2
      arrow-down
      1
      ·
      2 days ago

      D&D gives races a natural predisposition to certain behaviors. Orcs have to be brutal, elves have to be haughty, goblins have to be cowards, etc., it’s hard baked in the rules by being hard baked in the universe. While the D&Dverse does condemn racism, slavery, etc., the world keeps reinforcing racial essentialism by confirming those tropes. Plenty of scenarios/adventures are subversions of those tropes, only to end up with “yup, the orc was bad all along”, “yup, the drow was cruel all along”. It took until the 2020s for Wizards to get rid of the forced alignment charts for races. If you are an ethnicity that you can clearly feel is being represented by a race, and that race can only be evil and carries some real life racist tropes used against you, playing D&D as a youth feels really wrong. I hated creating characters, because the only ones I could connect with on a personal level were the ones with all the restrictions, although it took me until my adult years to properly understand why. By then it was too late to try and challenge those stereotypes by asking the DM to play a character that challenged the rules/lore.

      Drizzt is really annoying: the whole point is a rejection of this trope, but instead of showing that drows aren’t racially bad in an essentialised way, it shows that there is one miraculous exception to the rule. The “good one” trope beloved by fantasy authors, which lets them portray entire races as problematic, and sadly often give them traits that are racially loaded in the real world without really realizing it, by using the “it’s focused on the good one though” excuse.

      It’s amusing that you picked those two examples over the rest, since D&D and Drizzt were the two focuses of the thesis that spilled a lot of ink and anger, but spawned the conversation that eventually led to Wizards updating their racial policies, Roll to save vs prejudice: race in dungeons & dragons.

      • rumschlumpel@feddit.org
        link
        fedilink
        English
        arrow-up
        1
        ·
        1 day ago

        You only explained the point that I already agreed with (“always evil”-races is racism), and said nothing about the point that I actually asked about (slavery in D&D).

        • Bad@jlai.luOPM
          link
          fedilink
          English
          arrow-up
          1
          ·
          1 day ago

          Ah fair enough, it’s on me for not reading your comment properly (cheeky downvote spotted).

          I have no issues with the portrayal of slavery in either D&D or Drizzt.

          Adding the slavery bit was a specific dig at Harry Potter and the house elves, since it’s the most popular fantasy series around in the current zeitgeist, but it also fits a bunch of other “classic” fantasy series where slaves have no agency even after being freed / are fine with having a benevolent owner / reject freedom as a racial trait: Gor series as the most famous offender, Wheel of Time, the Empire trilogy, that one Dragon Age game, Star Wars, every single Isekai out there. It’s a common enough trope that there’s bound to be more examples, they just don’t come to mind right now, but I certainly wouldn’t consider it rare.

    • Bad@jlai.luOPM
      link
      fedilink
      English
      arrow-up
      3
      arrow-down
      6
      ·
      2 days ago

      Genuinely 75% of popular fantasy.

      Be glad that you don’t have the type of mind that likes to think about the deeper implications of a setting’s worldbuilding.

      Harry Potter, Chronicles of Gor, Wheel of Time, Chronicles of Narnia, Drizzt, Dungeon & Dragons, Conan the Barbarian, Twilight, Dragonlance, Redwall, every Isekai, the Belgariad… I’m actually having a harder time thinking of popular fantasy titles/series that don’t fit the trope. Even Tolkien confessed he struggled morally with the way he was portraying Orcs (but seemingly had no issue with the essentialism of other races), although he’s not a strong offender in this regard.

      • massive_bereavement@fedia.io
        link
        fedilink
        arrow-up
        4
        arrow-down
        2
        ·
        2 days ago

        Be glad that you don’t have the type of mind that likes to think about the deeper implications of a setting’s worldbuilding.

        The fuck is your problem?

        • Bad@jlai.luOPM
          link
          fedilink
          English
          arrow-up
          1
          arrow-down
          2
          ·
          edit-2
          2 days ago

          This was not a personal attack.

          I was answering your question. Growing up a minority / a target of systemic discrimination and using fantasy as an escape pushes you into a different way of interacting with lore and worldbulding, which leads to some painful questions about books and in some cases their authors too.

          Harry Potter was the most egregious, I was the right generation for everyone to be way into it, but the big segregation and slavery questions nobody seemed to care about had me confused. They were blocking issues for me. There are different ways to read a book, and you should be glad yours lets you enjoy the average fantasy book more than mine.

          Tolkien realized he had messed up by introducing the concept of the inherently racially evil race, since if that race is given any racial traits that can mirror real life racism (often accidentally), it will cause a major immersion issue for people who identify with those traits. He had planned to give orcs a proper origin story that would explain their behavior was not a choice iirc, and wanted to show how they became a regular civilization like any other after they were freed from their exploitation by Sauron, with good and bad people, art and culture, individual personalities. Sadly he didn’t have time to deliver that, and we are only left with his regrets, and with the people he influenced that don’t have the same critical approach he did to racial worldbuilding in fantasy.

          I see this has generated a negative response, but it’s not meant to be demeaning or negative in any way, quite the opposite actually, I wish my mind let me enjoy popular media in peace without overanalyzing them due to identifying with humiliating or offensive portrayals. It’s simply that the world of fantasy is even more uh… white-coded I guess than the average media, and I’m glad we’ve finally had a huge diversity breakthrough in SF&F during the past decade. Nobody should feel bad here, we’re all winners. If you still see a “problem” in this after my explanation then said problem is nothing more than the reflection you see in the mirror and has nothing to do with me 🤷‍♂️