[above image] : Abortion rights advocates protested the Supreme Court’s attack on women’s rights when it ended Roe. The Court is expected to intensify its attacks on democracy in the new term. Gemunu Amarasinghe/AP

  • betwixthewires@lemmy.basedcount.com
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    3
    arrow-down
    6
    ·
    1 year ago

    I’ve looked at those stats and I’m not really convinced.

    Half of gun deaths are suicides. In those cases, a desire to die is the cause of death. Something is deeply wrong in our society if children want to kill themselves in epidemic numbers, and we need to figure out what that is and fix it.

    Out of the rest, it’s almost entirely violence from organized crime. That violence doesn’t go away if you ban guns, at best other weapons get used, at worst criminals just don’t obey the gun laws. When two rival groups are fighting over a crack dealing monopoly in a neighborhood, if you blame the result of that on the tools used you’re ignoring another real problem. Why is America so addicted to drugs. Just like with suicide, I think we need to figure out what’s driving that.

    Something in our society is very very wrong, our society is sick and the symptoms are teen suicide (and veteran suicide and suicide as a result of divorce…) and widespread drug addiction. Guns show up in those dynamics simply because there are a lot of guns in America.

    • VikingHippie@lemmy.wtf
      link
      fedilink
      arrow-up
      4
      ·
      1 year ago

      I’ve looked at those stats and I’m not really convinced.

      Big surprise there 🙄

      Half of gun deaths are suicides. In those cases, a desire to die is the cause of death

      A gun is one of if not THE quickest and easiest ways to do it and, in the case of more difficult and lengthier methods, people can and surprisingly often WILL change their minds before it’s too late. No such opportunity with a bullet to the brain and thus an abundance of guns DOES contribute significantly to the number of suicides.

      Something is deeply wrong in our society if children want to kill themselves in epidemic numbers, and we need to figure out what that is and fix it.

      True, but that doesn’t mean that making it easier for them to act on that despair isn’t a bad idea.

      Out of the rest, it’s almost entirely violence from organized crime

      I’m gonna need a source on that.

      That violence doesn’t go away if you ban guns, at best other weapons get used, at worst criminals just don’t obey the gun laws

      Other weapons are less effective for easily killing, so their use in stead would significantly reduce the number of deaths.

      As for criminals not obeying gun laws, the overabundance of (at first) legally produced and sold for personal use guns makes it much easier for them to illegally aquire and use guns than it is in countries with stricter regulations.

      When two rival groups are fighting over a crack dealing monopoly in a neighborhood, if you blame the result of that on the tools used you’re ignoring another real problem

      The tools used makes it easier to kill and thus makes them more likely to kill. To ignore that means excess deaths.

      Why is America so addicted to drugs

      Drug abuse is mostly about genetic predisposition towards addiction, using the drugs to self-medicate or ignore other problems, or frequently both.

      The main problems connected to drug abuse and drug dealing are societal issues such as poverty, lack of opportunity and an oppressive society not giving some people any other options.

      Guns show up in those dynamics simply because there are a lot of guns in America.

      So close! There being a lot of guns exacerbates those “dynamics” dramatically, so the logical approach is to deal with the root causes AND the aggravating factors such as guns.

      In summary, more guns equal more deaths and thus common sense regulations are needed to save lives.

      • betwixthewires@lemmy.basedcount.com
        link
        fedilink
        arrow-up
        2
        arrow-down
        2
        ·
        1 year ago

        You’re going to need a source on the claim that most violent crime is in the furtherance of other profitable crime? You ever heard a phrase such as “if weed were legal then people wouldn’t kill each other selling weed”? I thought this was settled science. Is it so outlandish an idea that most people who kill do it because it is profitable for them to do so that you want me to google it for you?

        Alright, so let me ask you, what does “common sense” gun control look like?