unaware [they/them]

French in China

  • 27 Posts
  • 675 Comments
Joined 1 year ago
cake
Cake day: August 20th, 2025

help-circle
















  • The contradiction between the two main factions in the French Communist Party (PCF) is heightening this week, with half of the MPs of the communist and overseas group at the National Assembly announcing that they will support Jean-Luc Mélenchon (LFI) in the 2027 presidential election rather than the Party’s candidate Fabien Roussel, who was designated candidate by 72% of Party members. Here (Nitter) is a link to the MPs communiqué.

    There are two main reasons cited in the communiqué: 1. The threat of a far right victory in the next presidential elections. 2. Maintaining a big leftist coalition à la New Popular Front (NFP) can guarantee a victory of the radical left. As I’ll explain below, I think both of these are kinda bullshit. But before that, here is the list of signatories and their departements:

    Soumya Bourouaha, from Seine-Saint-Denis (Paris metro-area); Elsa Faucillon, from the Hauts-de-Seine (Paris metro-area); Émeline K/Bidi, from La Réunion (overseas); Karine Lebon, from La Réunion; Frédéric Maillot, from La Réunion; Marcellin Nadeau, from the Martinique (overseas); Stéphane Peu, from Seine-Saint-Denis; Nicolas Sansu, from Cher; Emmanuel Tjibaou, from Kanaky-New-Caledonia (colony).

    Edit: The PCF central committee just issued a communiqué condemning them and saying that they cannot speak in the name of the Party so long as they contradict the Party line, but not formally purging them.

    There are two main factions in the PCF and both are kinda shit (there is no more democratic centralism, but factions are still de jure forbidden, so lines are kinda blurry). The majority faction is one that I’d say is kind of a big tent, but the leadership is rather demsoc & kinda social-chauvinist. During the last presidential election (2022), they tried to court conservatives and Fabien Roussel became “right wingers’ favourite leftist candidate”, which is a terrible strategy; this election he’s trying to LARP as an actual communist for once lmao. Going by the votes for the “common base” text in the last congress (2026) the majority faction represents around 61% of the Party. The second one is called the “liquidators” by the rest of the Party, they’re succdems and demsocs, they are the ones that allied with Mélenchon in 2012 and 2017, and they were kicked out of the leadership by the current majority in 2018; they represented 25% in the last congress. The current majority was elected by Party members who felt that the Party was being erased on the national stage when allied with Mélenchon (true tbh), along with those that thought that the Party was becoming too succdem.

    ^By the way, there are more explicitly Marxist groups that presented two alternate texts last congress after allying with the majority in the previous congress (2023), which together got around 13% of the vote in the last congress :(.^

    However, there’s also a simpler, material difference between the two factions, which explains why this contradiction is sharpening at this current moment. If you noticed, the vast majority of MPs who rallied Mélenchon are from either the Parisian suburbs or overseas territories. In other words, their seats are from areas where LFI is by far the leading party on the left, unlike the majority faction. If they want to be reelected in new legislative elections (which will most likely happen just after the presidential elections), they have to make an alliance with LFI. This is precisely what happened under the NUPES (2022) and the NFP (2024), but the Party current leadership has betrayed these alliances very quickly (along with every other party except LFI tbf) since they lost big time from these alliances. This time round, LFI said earlier this year that an alliance for the legislative elections was only possible with parties that had also allied with them in the presidential elections. In other words, either the “liquidators” ally with LFI before the presidential elections, or they lose their seat to a new LFI MP in 2027.

    This, I think, is the actual reason for this split.

    CW: electoralism (from now on)

    Especially since the two reasons mentioned above are kinda bullshit. The far right is stagnating in France, and unless there is a Hindenburg moment they are going to have a hard time in the coming elections. They have always been overestimated in polling, but their actual results are surprisingly low. In 2022, when the traditional right wing party exploded (from 20% in 2017 to under 5% in 2022), Le Pen only got 23% of the vote (up only 2% from 2017), with 7% going to Zemmour (also far right) and the rest to others. With the centre exploding, the traditional Socialist Party voters will be pulled back to the left, while the traditional right wing will be able to recover from last election’s dreadful result. Le Pen’s party (RN), on the other hand, has been increasingly divided between its neoliberal Trumpist wing (under Bardella, who was reelected party president last month without opposition) and its more traditional false-social wing under Le Pen. The party leadership is divided on everything, except immigration, so they are forced to talk about immigration to avoid contraducting each other (and even then, sometimes they still do, such as during the ridiculous anti-hijab discourse from September). I think the far right will lose the election, and depending on how strong the post-centre candidates will be, maybe it’ll even lose the first round.

    Secondly, a big tent leftist alliance in the first round is a terrible way to beat the far right. In the case of Kamala Harris: sand all edges to avoid conflict within the alliance, so you don’t mobilise your base, so you lose in the end. Or, the Chile example, which would be more applicable to a Mélenchon-led alliance: elect a radical leftist (communist in Chile’s case), fail to mobilise the average brunch-goer, so you lead in the first round but have no momentum and are crushed in the second round. When you have two rounds, having multiple leftist candidates is a good thing: ideological struggle mobilises each party’s base, eventually helping the one who got to the second round; having multiple leftists in televised debates is better than one leftist vs 7 fascists à la Jubilee, etc.

    With the PCF having an actually somewhat communist campaign this time round, and actually arguing to the left of LFI now, it is a good thing that Fabien Roussel is a candidate. He’ll mobilise new voters and eventually his base will boost Mélenchon in the long round.