• 6 Posts
  • 93 Comments
Joined 10 months ago
cake
Cake day: January 18th, 2026

help-circle
  • A strike doesn’t seek to change the relation workers have with capitalists, only to achieve some progressive policy or reformist demands. A “social revolution” can include strikes, or evolve from strikes, but its main distinction is that it seeks to fundamentally change the relationship of workers and specifically their relation to private property and the means of production.

    A strike is an action that can lead to a revolution, but itself does not inherently seek to fundamentally change these relations. Likewise a “political revolution” also doesn’t seek to change these relationships and thus despite being a revolution, only accomplishes reforms.

    Its much like asking “what’s the difference between a wheel and a car” one is a component of a car but does not make a car. Likewise one is a component of revolution but does not mean revolution itself.

    PSL has a nice description of this that quotes Marx’s definitions here if you like: https://liberationschool.org/what-is-socialist-revolution/


  • It is no doubt difficult for you, as it is difficult for each and every revolutionary in different ways. Do not focus on what you can’t do, but what you can. Nearly every revolution so far was fought with the aid of people with nothing to their name. Even a portion of Kulaks (Who were described as having a petty bourgeois tendency) aided and fought with the bolsheviks revolution. George Jackson even organized within a prison.

    But we CAN do this! There is always work to be done! Even if they have tendencies it doesn’t not mean they are immune to noticing the contradictions of capitalism, or unwilling to aid in revolutionary activity. No matter what the conditions or circumstances there is potential to organize. One of the easiest things you can do is begin a study group with others, low commitment, low cost, and at least starts education. This can then expand to other activities.

    Believe in yourself. The bourgeois wants you pessimistic so you can never imagine a world beyond their control.


  • I’d argue that these groups are necessary, if not to be the revolutionary vanguard, but to help the revolutionary vanguard. Also serve as necessary training grounds to the unpracticed.

    The idea that nobody should put effort into a group because its not the vanguard when one doesn’t exist isn’t the best, in my opinion. (You did not say this, I should note clearly for anyone reading. You critique the focus on “big orgs” from marxists before supporting the participation in them. I only want to add to this line.)

    BPP was part of a rainbow coalition and Fred Hampton really pushed for uniting all workers. Huey P. Newton also advocated for white people to start a “white panther party” to support the black panther party. If we are to help ensure the future of socialism, and the success of the vanguard party, it is critical that we organize now, and gain the experience of practice and further our studies with other comrades and other oppressed peoples. This building of power and class consciousness among the most oppressed people will help bring about the support necessary to meet the conditions of revolution. Should a moment arise in which you can’t justify being with a party, or it acts against revolution. One can simply focus their efforts on another organization.

    Do not focus on a perfection, we most focus on agitating the people at the sharpest contradictions of the working class. We also, because of the time in which western marxists find themselves in a state of profound nihilism towards revolution(something I would say is a liberal tendency), must encourage our comrades to fight.

    We act as though the capitalist state only grows in strength. Yet if one were to apply historical dialectics one will find that the contradictions only sharpen. The people grow only more oppressed. And the solution to the struggles of the working class grows even more obvious to even the uninitiated worker.

    Without this “revolutionary optimism”, there is no chance for a revolution. Even with the perfect conditions.


  • I’ve been a part of DSA, several liberal organizations, and local ones, and PSL. There are options, the focus on financial contribution being the primary mode of helping an org is due to a lack of imagination I think. Labor contributions are immensely valuable for every organization.

    If you truly cant organize with any group at all and have exhausted all options, (which you also wont need to do for this step) simply take on the task of organizing in your local community. No matter how small or how big the community is. If you’re in a town of 40,000 then 30 people is already a fairly decent influence. In my personal organizing efforts I’ve made groups that broke 50 twice.

    You take the theory you have and you apply it in practice, start with people you trust, then people they trust, and so on. Even if your group doesn’t grow extremely large or burn down capitalism in your specific area its invaluable practice.




  • The idea that you are being constantly surveilled is a bit of a propaganda thing. There is no doubt a bunch of data being collected from your digital signature. But the Idea that anyone is looking at it isn’t very realistic. Especially if you’re not actively participating/leading a large revolutionary movement.

    They want you to fear so much that you never act. Have escape plans and minimize the information given and poison the information is just about the best you can do. But the sacrifices and practices you’ve made are inspiring and no doubt impactful on your safety. Not to mention the skills you learned doing such.

    It doesn’t occupy my mind outside of stuff I try to keep hidden. For that you can always just have a conversation away from tech in the middle of the woods or something.


  • The failures of socialists is something to be angry at. But acts of adventurism and accelerationism don’t help build a movement. If they did, places under extreme oppression would have spontaneous social revolutions. We find in history its quite the opposite. While harsh conditions might sharpen the contradictions, it is the vanguard party that is the missing piece to a successful peoples revolution.

    I know it feels frustrating, and being in the west can make one feel hopeless and powerless. But it is this exact feelings capitalists want you to have. They want you to get so desperate you try to rile people in an act of adventurism or violence that only serves to satisfy yourself.

    I totally understand the frustration, but this is a machine bigger than the act one one person. We have to stand together and organize. When we act alone we just fall. There have been several acts of terror done by single individuals in America against the ruling class. But they are caught or killed and it never sparks a wider movement. People must be agitated, and organized. If you must get this energy out, do it in radical agitation. If it just makes you angrier then direct it into a hobby.


  • Japanese X has pretty consistently hosted some horrible voices. I follow and engage with topics in Japanese as I speak it and it is not good.

    Thankfully, like most of the internet, its not the norm. Most Japanese people are just liberals who don’t care like anywhere else in the west. They are also mostly pro Palestine and against their state and America supporting the genocide.


  • CURRICULUM OF THE BASIC PRINCIPLES OF MARXISM-LENINISM- This is a book that is translated from Vietnams education course on Marxism Leninism by Luna Oi.

    Other Sciences don’t depend on you researching the original works (Which are usually early 1900 intellectuals discussing complex material to each other when they already have a baseline) to understand material. They’re dissected by scholars and made into a format that is easier to learn.

    The translated books by Luna Oi, which is two books at this point in time, contains annotations to describe concepts that students in the curriculum would already know by the time they begin working with the books. Its an excellent starting resource for people who are just beginning understanding Marxism, and also for people who might struggle with some topics.

    Invaluable resource and I believe the first book is archived but you can also support her efforts to translate by purchasing one. I cannot recommend it enough for new marxists. The first half of the first book is all about dialectical materialism.


  • I don’t need to see my opponent as evil, committing evil is enough. I do not need to analysis the character of someone who commits acts of genocide to find if he is truly evil, or somehow mistaken. It needs to be stopped first and foremost. The amount I call them evil or good does not change from my willingness to commit violence to stop their evil acts.

    I think the argument over the label isn’t as important as analyzing the relationship between a suffering body and its perpetrators. Should a man be lynched by a mob it is natural for him and his folk to call them evil. But this does not increase violence against the mob. No the real requirements are both, identifying something as being the cause of suffering and also the power, and confidence to act.

    While yes, reactionary figures can weaponize such labels for committing atrocious acts, the context needs to be considered. You are in a Marxist thread full of people who apply dialectical materialist analysis. Not a bunch of idle minded reactionaries. Just with a simple consideration of the context, America and Cuba, will tell you who is the aggressor and “Evil” in the relationship. One is perpetuating a genocide and killing the people of Cuba and its children for DARING to take control of their own future, and end the exploitation of America.

    America, charged with multiple counts of genocide across the world across many people. Is not just undeniably evil, but also unapologetically so. Even beyond the context of Cuba, America is constantly imperializing the people of the world. Exploiting them for their labor, stealing their resources, and murdering any who resist, or simply are unable to find work.

    Calling someone Evil does not make one more willing to commit violence. What is required is only the power and organization to commit violence. With calling someone evil only contributing to the support of the violence. If Evil was first required we would not have ever had slaves. Especially slaves born as slaves. How can one justify the violence of enslavement on a person who has yet to act in any regard on anything. No, infact love was used to justify violence just as equally in American History. The white man so “loved” the slave that rather than leave him on his own he had to act as a parent to the slave. Even at times the slave was considered “Part of the family”. Not to mention the violence parents may commit unto their kids. This does not require that the kid be labeled “evil” first.

    First one must have the capacity to commit violence. This is the first and most important feature of it. Then someone must have a target, usually weaker than them. They then have a desired outcome of their violence, something they expect to happen once they unleash it. THEN they justify the violence, it is only at this point that the label might contribute to ones capacity. After they have already committed to acting, visualizing the desired outcome. Only after this point does one consider a justification for their violence. This is why it is not required to be called “evil” or to even have a reason.

    America is cartoonishly Evil. The label does not make it so, but its actions do. This conversation and analysis would better serve a group of reactionaries who are falling to some kind of reactionary violence like Racism, Homophobia, Transphobia, etc


  • This is why liberal allyship is so performative: it’s not about helping marginalized people, whom they view as subhuman unless they happen to be in an overlapping demographic (white), it’s about making them feel like they’re good people without having to give up the illusion of comfort and safety.

    Fuck that’s so fucking accurate and it’s insane that it’s been said for decades.

    You’re absolutely right, I was actually missing my own advice in not focusing on recruiting people that refuse to learn, and instead focus on those willing to make a difference and organize, thanks.


  • I would love to collect info on these if you have any on hand. I’ve been having some beef in this Trans group with a couple people who are very against the idea we can move beyond the democratic party. I’m not even trying to tell them to all militarize right fucking now but do something to start their self liberation. Even taking the smallest peak into POC history, especially black movements throughout the United states history, would show what backing liberals does. This has all been examined before.

    Thankfully most agreed with me, but the dialogue that’s been had has been depressing. I even had someone who’s organizing a YDSA chapter start bashing me about how “helpful democrats have been in stopping trumps plans from happening and he complains about it all the ti~me on truth social.” So much for solidarity while I’m actively agitating people. I have been arguing for Liberals historical abandonment of minorities, but that would really help with more recent bashing. I remember they did it but I have trouble finding it recently, I had asked in an actual post on trans topics but this would also help put more baggage on democrats.


  • Paywall so here’s this paste of the text. Hope I didn’t get this messed up.

    ICE Is Running One of the Largest Anti-Left Surveillance Operations in US History ICE’s Homeland Security Investigations is engaged in far-reaching spying against left-wing activists that rivals the FBI and CIA crackdowns on the Civil Rights and anti-war movements.

    Attorneys for 15 Minnesota residents facing federal conspiracy charges have obtained evidence of a sweeping, possibly unconstitutional spying operation carried out by Immigration and Customs Enforcement against left-wing social movements in Minnesota and beyond.

    The high-profile Minnesota 15 prosecution makes clear that the Department of Homeland Security (DHS), flush with federal funds and newly hired personnel, is now President Donald Trump’s primary tool against dissent, with a powerful array of post-9/11 investigative authorities brought to bear against everyday Americans organizing their communities.

    Nothing of this scale has been seen in the United States, experts say, since the federal government’s counterinsurgency against the New Left and the anti-war movement in the 1960s and 1970s.

    Among the records revealed during the discovery process in these cases are dozens of reports, audio transcripts, emails, intercepted Signal chats, photographs, database queries, and more. They reveal the inner workings of the domestic terrorism investigations, running under the names Project Whipple Shield and Operation Puppet Master, authorized by the controversial National Security Presidential Memorandum 7.

    Published following Charlie Kirk’s assassination in September of last year, NSPM 7 instructs federal law enforcement to use every tool available against organizations and people who criticize the administration’s policies and espouse “anti-Christian” ideas. The full scope and extent of the investigations it authorizes remains unknown.

    Defense attorneys for the Minnesota 15 claim that the prosecution stems from a broader nationwide surveillance operation aimed at opponents of the Trump administration’s immigration policies. One attorney in the case directly compares the DHS-run campaign to the FBI’s infamous Counterintelligence Program, or COINTELPRO, which unconstitutionally surveilled, infiltrated, and blackmailed racial justice, civil rights, and anti-war movements from the 1950s through the early 1970s.

    Three former law enforcement officials who reviewed filings concur, telling WIRED that the case is almost certainly part of a wider intelligence-gathering operation that began long before the administration invaded Minnesota in December 2025.

    Dueling motions in the case over discovery of DHS’s surveillance program reveal that personnel with Homeland Security Investigations—one of ICE’s two components—repurposed funding mechanisms and investigative tools for serious criminal probes and turned them on domestic dissenters. Operation Keyhole, the HSI undercover program that bankrolled the Minnesota 15 prosecution, dates back to 2008. As of June 2026, it was underwriting a half dozen active undercover investigations in the Minneapolis–Saint Paul area.

    Around 120 HSI agents, many drawn from specialized units across the country that have served as the leading edge of the administration’s militarized immigration enforcement operations, were assigned to the case—including 11 undercovers. They used highly invasive surveillance techniques, including the deployment of Reaper drones and Patriot Act tools usually restricted to money laundering and terrorism investigations. Undercover operatives also infiltrated churches in apparent violation of a court order.

    The Minnesota 15 indictment stems from the Trump administration’s demand that the Justice Department “go big and go loud” to crack down on community response networks during last winter’s Operation Metro Surge. Twin Cities activists organized volunteers to monitor DHS agents and their vehicles using encrypted Signal groups, homebuilt vehicle databases, and a centralized dispatch system. Government prosecutors claim that this amounts to a criminal conspiracy to block immigration enforcement, unlawfully identify and stalk federal agents, and even assault them.

    Their defense attorneys say the heavy charges filed against the Minnesota 15 don’t align with their alleged conduct. “This is the first time I’ve had a client who’s accused of a conspiracy and went on a speaking tour,” says Kevin Riach, who represents defendant Isaac Sant.

    An internal ICE document laying out the scope of Operation Puppet Master—which led to the indictment of the Minneapolis 15—ends by noting, “This case has also been accepted under CUC Op Keyhole.” According to prosecutors, Operation Keyhole is a long-standing program created by HSI’s Saint Paul office to fund “undercover activity”—primarily equipment purchases and personnel costs—in a region covering Minnesota, North and South Dakota, Iowa, and Nebraska. The program has funded at least 77 investigations into “narcotics trafficking, child sexual abuse, financial investigations, and counter-proliferation” since it started in December 2008.

    The CUC prefix, per an internal 2008 DHS handbook unearthed by the independent media outlet Unicorn Riot, refers to Certified Undercover Operations, a formal designation with clearly defined oversight mechanisms, procedures, and reporting requirements. Operation Keyhole’s parameters are reviewed every six months by a committee comprising senior DOJ and DHS officials. As of June 2026, when it was last renewed, Keyhole funded six active investigations, including Project Whipple Shield, which was initiated in February to probe claims of assault, stalking, and doxing of DHS agents and other federal employees, and underpins the Minnesota 15 indictment.

    At least 11 undercover agents working under Operation Keyhole infiltrated Twin Cities anti-ICE activists, participating in martial arts and know-your-rights trainings, marches, general strikes, and community meetings. They also infiltrated activists’ communications network for identifying possible undercover ICE vehicles and dispatching activists to tail them through the Twin Cities, and penetrated several activist group chats on Signal, transmitting their contents back to other HSI colleagues for analysis and eventual inclusion in the indictment.

    Activist conferences as far away as Seattle, Michigan, Chicago, and New York City were placed under surveillance as part of the investigation, and HSI teams photographed and ran the license plates of every car parked in the lot of a meeting location or seen transporting activists. There is also drone footage from unarmed Customs and Border Protection Reaper drones of the activists moving around the Twin Cities area.

    The undercovers were part of a much broader group of more than 50 HSI agents, including at least two dozen from HSI’s little-known Special Operations Group, that took part in the investigation and surveillance of the defendants, both digital and in-person. Feds with decades of experience on complex financial crimes, drug cartel investigations, human trafficking, and organized crime were pulled into the Minnesota 15 investigation.

    Several of the Minnesota 15 case agents are from out of state and appear in court records for the prosecutions of anti-ICE activists in other cities. This includes Los Angeles–based HSI agents Robert Kurtz III, who specializes in financial fraud, and Ryan Ribner, who allegedly assaulted SEIU California president David Huerta at a June 2025 protest of an ICE enforcement operation, arrested him, and then claimed the then 58-year-old Huerta attacked federal law enforcement. (Huerta’s charges were dropped in July after videos contradicting Ribner’s account surfaced.) HSI records show Ribner was also involved in at least two prosecutions of Southern California residents who physically confronted ICE and Border Patrol agents last year.


  • Attempting to lecture on morality from a position of having never been a victim of violence is a very bold and privileged position. I hope you understand the limits of people to understand such a state of “nirvana”.

    I would argue the dismissal of sources of violence and oppression as being “morally gray” is in itself a kind of simplification. If everyone and everywhere is morally grey, you never have to pick a side to bash and can always lecture the side committing violence at the time.

    A slave is not wrong for falling for propaganda to call his slave master evil. The slave master is not morally grey, and so to is the system that perpetuates it. Yes, even if the slave master lives a better life because of this exploitation.



  • If anything my poltical stances have granted me MORE friends. Before I was only friends with a small circle of people directly related to the area around me and I would lose them as they moved away or became interested in other things. However I have gained a ton of friends just for being unapologetically communist. Everything from other ML’s, Professors, and people who arent interested in politics.

    My agitation comes from a place of understanding so I don’t really ever end up with arguments with people and always take the position of I could be wrong. But I’m sure I’ve also gotten very lucky in the people I meet. Obviously there are people who are too aggressively reactionary to really get close with and it might be that by being outspoken I’ve attracted people who are more accepting to the ideas.