I know, it’s an unpopular opinion. But for me Lemmy is not better than Reddit and Mastodon is not the New Twitter. They are something on reddit that I didn’t find on Lemmy. Here there are obviously less people and less community and it’s for the entire fediverse : the age of the population is incredibly high ! And for me the main subjects (politic, leftism etc…) is… sorry but … I’m not interested about that so its vers boring to see my lemmy or mastodon feed when 90% of the content are political-content, its for me the main problem of the fediverse.
Another user’s unpopular opinion gets downvoted in c/UnpopularOpinion, despite them having a reasonable explanation for their thoughts. Your complaints are valid, and I wish this place was more active too. Many of the fediverse equivalents of the subreddits I enjoyed before the exodus rarely get posts or are actually abandoned, and that’s if someone bothers making one at all. Even the ones that are active still get a small fraction of the discussion that their subreddit would get. Also, there’s more fracturing and inter-community drama, with instances fully defederalizing with other insances because of problems with certain communities there. And naturally the apps available are much less mature.
Lemmy is excellent for leftist politics, tech enthusiasts, and some other select interests. But it doesn’t really let you discover things or integrate into a community well. Filtering out things that I have little interest in leaves very little, whereas Reddit was big enough for me to be very picky in flitering while still including all kinds of niche things in my custom feed. I still often search for reddit posts if I want to learn from an informed community perspective or get a guide for something.
I hope more people give this a chance, because it really does avoid issues with company-owned social media, but I guess it’s hard for people to overcome inertia and make the switch.
The issue i see is that a huge influx of users came and tried to make lemmy like reddit.
So a large amount of niche communities started on a number of instances.
Whereas they organically grew on Reddit (ie, when /r/TV got too busy with The Boys posts, /r/TheBoys started as a community (these are just made up examples)).
I wish that lemmy had more concentrated communities on related instances (so lemmy.film.social is all about Movie communities). And communities would only specialise when the related generic community gets too busy.