- cross-posted to:
- right2repair@discuss.tchncs.de
- cross-posted to:
- right2repair@discuss.tchncs.de
You must log in or # to comment.
Louis has a tendency to ramble so I’ll give you the tl:dw
Google plans to make parts available but not at the level that they should, so they’ll continue to be absurdly expensive to the point that you might as well just buy a new one.
More specifically they don’t make “parts” available but “parts assemblies” - a large collection of parts attached together. Replacing one part requires buying ones you do not need and replacement is merely a fallback when you can’t actually repair the part. To repair a part you need it’s parts (e.g. a chip on a circuit board).
Ah, so this is effectively identical to Apple’s approach to repairability.
No, I don’t think Apple sells any components at all and they intentionally make sure the phone doesn’t work properly after you replace them.
Apple sells parts and rents tool kits.
They sell a select few parts, from which you’re FORCED to rent these stupid and unnecessary tool kits and then spend all day on the phone with Apple getting them to completely unnecessarily approve the repair with their servers.
E: this option isn’t even listed on their website. Only options listed are to send it in or get it done at a “3rd party authorized repair” store.
Yep. If your USB port breaks, they want you to replace the entire motherboard for a thousand bucks.
In other words, they took the Apple approach to right to repair. Disappointing but not unexpected. This is the same company that got rid of their “don’t be evil” motto after all.
For the people in the comments not in the know: Rossmann is a respected voice for this sort of thing, even if this post looks like an ad. He’s not one of the bad ones (yet).
this guy is insufferable. these videos are just unnecessarily long speeches that would fit an article so much better than a video.
not to mention that his whole YouTube/Odysee channel is disguised advertisement for their businesses.
Yeah he rambles in his videos, sometimes so much I want him to just stick to the topic, and he could benefit from writing a script, but calling someone “insufferable” because of that seems pretty harsh, especially when they’ve been a massive proponent of right to repair (and even successfully had some laws changed), open source, and privacy.
This guy was offered an insane salary for doing engineering for US defense contracts and turned it down because he felt like calling out bad practices and improving repairability on our devices was a better thing to do. I can respect that. Someone putting their principles before simply making as much bank as possible.
Yeah, he has a link to his repair business in his video description and occasionally mentions he has a repair business or bullshit anti-repair stuff the repair shop has to deal with. I don’t see what’s so bad about that.
Not everyone has the time, ability, or tools to repair everything themselves at home. Repair shops are a good thing. Would you rather things just be discarded when the battery dies or the screen gets a crack?
This guy was offered an insane salary for doing engineering for US defense contracts and turned it down because he felt like calling out bad practices and improving repairability on our devices was a better thing to do.
I guess that makes him our lord and saviour then, and we can then only take him seriously because of that. Knowing this changes everything. He is so good to help us lowly people in our quest for repairable devices! And if you just keep watching his videos he can teach you how you also can be successful like him. And by the way you can buy his tools too!
He’s right on the right to repair, but every time I tried to watch his videos (and I tried a few times, I work in tech and like the subject), I always felt like I was being… patronized.
Cool story bro. Keep crying about people who do good things.
Ok fanboi.
I don’t watch any YouTube anymore, but good try.
Keep crying about people who are pro right to repair and actively spend resources to fight companies who want to erode those rights, loser.
Your phone manufacturer doesn’t love you. They don’t even know you exist.
You know it’s not one or another, right?
I’ve been using Linux since 1999 and I’m a strong defender of free software. I’ve been rooting and installing roms on my phones for years. I’ve repaired them several times. I’m well aware of the issues and I still have the right not to like Louis Rossman, even if I support his cause with the right to repair.
I don’t think it’s necessary to tell people they are losers because they don’t like him. We are not ennemies. Some people can actually dislike him, or his style, and still support the cause. But if you want to antagonize them…
You’re the one antagonising lmao, get a grip and stop being a whiny loser.
You see someone doing something good and your first instinct is to cry about it.
I really liked his relaxing, calm MacBook repair and data recovery videos, where you could learn about soldering and electronics repair while watching. And I had no problem with a little bit of honest advertising for his own business.
While the right to repair is important, his videos about it are a lot of rambling and complaining about the same thing again and again. The titles are also often misleading or click baity. I can’t watch them either. I hope they work for the right people, though.
But if you just watch his videos and buy his stuff he will teach you how to repair yours!11! /s
The few times I watched his videos, he sounded like a libertarian bro, saying that if you just put the effort, you too can become successful. You just have to pull yourself by the bootstraps or something. He’s showing you everything you need to know to be as successful as him! And maybe it was sarcasm and I didn’t catch it but at one point he muttered something about Trump fixing the potholes of New York. That’s about when I stopped taking him seriously.
He’s still an important voice for the right to repair movement but you’re right. I also can’t stand him. Unfortunately he has very dedicated/vocal eeehm, fans, so legitimate remarks on him are often met with downvotes.
For the last 3 years he’s been saying it’s no longer possible to be successful financially doing what he does. He did used to say that, though, because at one point it was true.
I totally agree. I didn’t know him until I saw a couple of his videos posted in Lemmy and I can’t stand the guy.
At this point I’d guess that the reason for his rambles is to make more money through monetisation.
Why does it feel like this post is an ad?
Posting the URL grabbed the first line of the video description which is an ad for his repair business.
A person who repairs is talking about right to repair.
Right to repair benefits consumers, whether he makes money from it or not
Selling only a bundle of parts that cost near the price of a new one is worth diddly to consumers. Third party repair is a benefit for consumers and they need individual parts and scematic to repair.
because it is. Every time I see one of this guy’s videos posted it ends up being a clickbait video to promote his business.
Just typical shitty YouTube clickbaiting
deleted by creator
deleted by creator
